First, I’ll lead by saying I’m a guy who has now had both kinds of threesomes. Despite the FMF variety being one of my biggest fantasies and all, I found that what happened in reality did not live up to my expectations of it. I felt a lot of pressure to perform and felt bad when I came really quickly (sensory overload!). I was also preoccupied with trying to spend equal time with both girls because I was slightly paranoid my GF would get jealous since we are new to this stuff. Basically was just unable to really let go, and while I had a good time it wasn’t perfect.
However, we had agreed to try both kinds of threesomes, so it was her turn to be in the middle and receive more pleasure than she could ever imagine. We made a post on the r4r subreddit asking for guys who were down to share a lady with me and got a lot of responses. We looked through them together and picked a guy who she thought was attractive and who seemed nice based on our PM conversation with him. For the rest of the story, I’ll use fake names for privacy’s sake, but here’s how it went down. We’ll call my GF “Sarah” and the third guy “Eric.”
We met at a bar a couple blocks from our apartment, so it would be easy to get back there if we wanted this to go down. Neither of us had never done anything like this before, meeting a stranger for a possible sexual encounter, but it was surprisingly easy. Once we found each other at the bar, we got a table on the outside patio and had no trouble at all having nice conversation between the three of us. Eric was a small business owner only a few years older than us (impressive!), who was in town on business for a week. After a couple of pitchers between the three of us, Eric excused himself to go to the bathroom and I asked Sarah “Should we go for this?” She looked at me, nodded, and said “lets get out of here.”
Back at our place with him, we sat on the couch and smoked some bowls out of my vaporizer, all of us knowing what was coming next but unsure of how to get things started. I turned to Sarah and whispered in her ear “Just go over there, sit on his lap and start kissing him.” That should get things going pretty quickly. That it did.
Mid-sentence in our conversation, Sarah stood up, grabbed the cup of water out of his hand, set it on the table, and straddled him in the chair. She kissed him, first with a little bit of hesitation, but then with this fiery passion that I’ve only seen when she was the horniest of horny. Light kisses turned into full on making out, and as I sat there watching them, the full realization of what was happening hit me. “I’m watching my GF make out with another guy, and it’s turning me on more than anything.”
They were going at it, hands were all over, and the clothes were coming off. I was sitting there just taking in the sights, fantasizing about what would happen next. Sarah wasted no time, getting up and yelling “Bedroom, NOW” at both of us. At this point she was down to these sexy little purple boyshorts and a blue polka dotted bra, spread out on the bed, shaking her butt at us. We started by both giving her a massage, putting our hands all over her body, rubbing, teasing, making her want us. She looked like she was in heaven, feeling the sensation of multiple sets of hands caressing her and the reality that she had two men all to herself. The moans were frequent, she was squirming all over the bed, and we hadn’t even taken her panties off yet. When I went to do that, she had soaked all the way through the fabric and the wetness was literally dripping out onto the bed. I don’t think I’d ever seen her this wet before. I looked at Eric and said “Feel how wet her pussy is, it’s incredible.” He stroked it with his finger and said “Wow.”
Sarah looked at me and said “why are you still wearing clothes?,” which was a pretty good question. I quickly got naked, and the fun really began. Eric and I teamed up on the foreplay, taking turns going down on her and using our fingers while the other one focused on her face, neck, and breasts. We switched positions frequently, sometimes she had one of our cocks in her mouth while the other one was going down on her, sometimes she was kissing one of us while the other massaged her and teased her all over. With his cock in her mouth, Eric said to me “Man, she’s good at this. You are a lucky man.”
Sarah was insatiable, demanding my cock in her mouth and writhing in pleasure as he finger-fucked her while kissing her thighs and her huge clit. “Face fuck me!” She yelled. I thrust my cock in and out of her mouth as he got a little more rough with his fingers bringing her closer and closer to orgasm. While I fucked her face I was using my hands and mouth to play with her nipples, while he was continuing to please her pussy and kiss her thighs. Her eyes rolled into the back of her head and she started shaking and screaming, her entire body pulsating, squirming, feeling the sensation that can only come from an extra pair of hands. Her orgasm felt like it lasted forever, at least twice as long as I’d ever seen her go before. She took my cock out of her mouth and just laid there spread out, clit dripping with wetness and nipples rock hard, taking in what had just happened to her. But of course she wasn’t done yet’
